Episode 208: Choosing a Care Provider with Dr. Stu (Dr. Stuart Fischbein)
Childbirth is one of the most significant experiences in a person’s life, and leading up to it is filled with decisions that can feel empowering and overwhelming.
In this podcast episode, a thoughtful conversation unfolded around the realities of the medical model of care, the importance of self-advocacy, and what it means to trust your instincts during pregnancy and birth. At the heart of the discussion was a simple but powerful message: you have more agency than you realize.
Before labor ever begins, there is an opportunity for reflection. One of the speakers, an experienced obstetrician who has worked in both hospital and out-of-hospital settings, emphasized the importance of understanding your values early in pregnancy, or even before becoming pregnant. Where do you feel safest giving birth? How do you feel about medical interventions such as induction or cesarean birth? Do you envision having a doula or midwife present? These questions are not about creating rigid expectations but about clarifying what matters most to you. When you are grounded in your values, decision-making becomes clearer, even when circumstances shift.
A significant part of the conversation centered on fear and how it can shape medical care. Pregnancy often carries a heightened sense of responsibility and vulnerability, making expectant parents especially sensitive to risk. In many traditional medical settings, providers are trained within a framework that prioritizes worst-case scenarios. While safety is crucial, fear-based communication can unintentionally transfer anxiety to patients. Understanding this dynamic allows you to pause and ask questions rather than immediately react. Supportive care does not dismiss risk, it contextualizes it.
Choosing a healthcare provider is one of the most important steps in the process. The episode encouraged listeners to reframe the first prenatal visit as an interview rather than a passive appointment. This is your opportunity to assess whether a provider aligns with your philosophy of birth. Do they welcome questions? Do they respect differing preferences? Do you leave the appointment feeling reassured or unsettled? Your emotional response matters. If you consistently feel anxious, dismissed, or confused, that may be a sign to explore other options. Feeling heard and respected should not be considered a luxury; it is foundational.
The discussion also highlighted specific questions that can open meaningful dialogue with providers. Asking about policies on induction, approaches to post-term pregnancy, comfort with breech birth, support for VBAC, fetal monitoring practices, labor positions, eating during labor, and the role of doulas can provide insight into how flexible or protocol-driven a practice may be. These conversations are not about confrontation. They are about clarity. When you understand a provider’s typical approach, you can better determine whether it aligns with your preferences.
Another powerful topic addressed was the label of “high-risk pregnancy.” The term itself can feel alarming, yet there is no universally fixed definition. Often, it simply means that certain factors increase the likelihood of complications compared to an average baseline. However, what qualifies as “average” varies widely across hospitals and communities. Being over 35, having had a previous cesarean, or carrying twins may automatically trigger a high-risk label in some settings. While risk factors should be taken seriously, they should also be explained clearly and placed into perspective. Increased monitoring does not automatically mean inevitable intervention. Asking your provider to walk you through actual statistics and individualized risk can reduce unnecessary stress and restore a sense of balance.
The episode strongly encouraged seeking second opinions when faced with recommendations that feel rushed or unclear. Medicine is not infallible, and respectful providers understand the value of collaborative decision-making. Seeking additional input is not disloyal or dramatic, it is proactive. When you gather information from multiple qualified sources, you strengthen your ability to make decisions confidently.
For many women, advocating for themselves in medical settings can feel unfamiliar. Questioning authority may feel uncomfortable, especially in high-stakes moments. One of the most helpful reframes shared in the conversation was to approach advocacy with curiosity instead of confrontation. Asking, “Can you help me understand why this is necessary?” invites dialogue rather than defensiveness. Curiosity opens doors. It transforms appointments from directive encounters into collaborative conversations.
Ultimately, the conversation returned again and again to trust, not blind trust, but informed trust. Trust in your ability to learn. Trust in your instincts when something feels off. Trust in your capacity to ask questions. Birth is unpredictable, and flexibility is important, but empowerment comes from knowing you participated actively in your decisions.
Childbirth is not just a medical event; it is a life-altering experience that often shapes how a mother remembers the beginning of her parenting journey. Investing time in understanding your options, clarifying your values, and choosing supportive providers can dramatically influence how you feel about your birth story. When you approach pregnancy with both openness and discernment, you create space for a collaborative experience that honors safety without sacrificing autonomy.
You deserve care that respects your voice. You deserve information that empowers rather than intimidates. And most importantly, you deserve to walk into your birth experience knowing that your instincts matter.
Connect with Dr. Stu:
Website: www.birthinginstincts.com/drstu
Instagram: birthinginstincts
Facebook: DrStuartFischbein
Relevant Links:
Hypnobabies is a great tool to use hypnosis when preparing for childbirth. Use the code MOTHERHOOD20 to receive 20% off today!
Truly fuel your body with FOND Bone Broth a verified regenerative by land to market company dedicated to serving you rich and handcrafted items. Use code ENTERINGMOTHERHOOD for 10% off.
Looking to become a doula yourself and get into birthwork? Check out the Online Doula Training Program to get started on your path today.
Become certified through Postpartum University and help clients learn more about how to nourish their bodies in the postpartum period.
Want a baby carrier you can snuggle your baby tight in? Check out LoveHeld for their handwoven ring sling carrier you'll be sure to love.
In need of nursing tops and postpartum items? Kindred Bravely is the place to shop for all of your attire needs and more.
